Selling: more like Mining than Manufacturing

Prospector

Prospecting for mineral ore deposits is hard work. Prospectors travel on foot or horseback in desolate locations and under harsh conditions. Traversing stream beds and outcrops, they pan and sift looking for indications of viable deposits.

It’s physically demanding to comb the countryside, searching for exposed material in creek beds, rock outcrops, and ridge lines. Once prospectors find an occurrence of the ore, then they work that area to evaluate its viability using pick and shovel or a simple machine like a sluice box. Often these occurrences are short-lived and produce little of value, forcing the prospector to keep looking.

Selling as a production activity is more like this prospector than manufacturing. Unlike Manufacturing, which can order high quality raw materials from a catalog, Marketing and Sales has little control over its raw material. Before it can create a customer, it must find the raw material of potential buyers.

  • Sales people often are expected to find and qualify potential customers on their own.
  • Each sales person has a method, but little sharing of best practices goes on.
  • In some shops sales people actually compete with each other, further diminishing the possibility of sharing successful prospecting methods.
  • Shops have little common definition of what constitutes a lead or a qualified prospect, so sales people often spend time on prospective buyers that will go nowhere
  • Marketing conducts activities that create broad awareness about the company and its products. But their efforts often deliver too little information about where sales people should put their energy (too few leads). Or they deliver information about too many places to look (too many poor leads), most of which are not good material.

The mining industry of course no longer relies on the lone prospector with his pickax and sluice box. The industry has developed engineering techniques to gain more control over the process of looking for raw material.

Similarly, Marketing can be more systematic about how it finds the raw material of potential buyers that it can deliver to Sales.

Mary and Michael Molloy suggest this method for getting started:

  • Establish your goals: Define what products you are selling, who you are selling it to, where they are located, the industries they work in, and the channels of distribution you’ll use. By defining more precisely your ultimate target, you’ll be able to focus your efforts more effectively.
  • Profile your target customer audience: Now that you have a definition of success, it’s time to profile your ideal prospect. Before you can search for raw material, you have to know what your buyers look like. Who are they? What’s important to them? And, most important, what problem would your ideal prospect have that you are the best company to fix? Your market is composed of businesses who suffer most from this problem and who are the most prepared to pay money to have it fixed.

You’ll never be able to order prospects from a catalog the way Manufacturing orders its raw material. But with a more systematic approach you’ll gain control and predictability over the first stage of customer creation, finding high quality potential buyers.

Learning from the principles of Lean and Six Sigma

Extended exposure of the night sky with Polaris, the North Star, in the center of the star trails.

Extended exposure of the night sky with Polaris, the North Star, in the center of the star trails.

Principles are the essence of our work. They don’t change with time or place, technology or tactics, conditions or context. They are a constant reference point to guide us.

Lean and Six Sigma are two well-established initiatives that organizations use to improve how they do their work. Making a process Lean improves its productivity, and Six Sigma is used to improve quality.

All Lean and Six Sigma initiatives are built upon the same set of core principles. These principles can be applied to Sales and Marketing as well as to any process in an organization. Sales and Marketing groups that hew to these principles will deliver more customers, bigger deals, and more profitable revenue to their company.

Marketing and Sales: advancing the buyer’s journey

The process of Sales and Marketing revolves around the buying cycle. Sales and Marketing creates value that motivates buyers to move from stage to stage in their journey.

The Buyer's Journey

The Buyer's Journey

Buyers don’t start out thinking “Hmm, of the products that solve this problem, which one should I buy?” No, they start out unaware that the problem even exists. They then proceed through a series of stages from becoming aware, to looking for solutions, and to making a decision. The job of Sales and Marketing is to help your buyers move smoothly through those stages.

Lean: removing friction to increase customer flow

The goal of making a process more Lean is to remove unnecessary actions (waste) from the system and to cause the process to flow more smoothly. Lean methods have their origin in the production system at Toyota, a story that James Womack and Daniel Jones tell well in The Machine that Changed the World and elaborate in Lean Thinking.

The principles of Lean are:

  • Specify value – Value is defined by the customer. In Sales and Marketing, value is what meets the specific needs of the buyer at each stage of the Buying Cycle. Value is what buyers are willing to take action to obtain to answer their questions and solve their problems at each stage. This action could be to read a white paper, to visit your website, to see a demo or to review a proposal.
  • Identify the value stream – For each type of buyer at each company, the value stream is the sequence of value creation steps that support the customer’s buying cycle.
  • Flow – Make the value stream flow faster by removing obstacles that create friction for the buyer. Increase the motivation of the buyer to move forward in the Buying Cycle by showing the alignment of the buyer’s goals and your goals.
  • Pull – Once your value stream flows, then it is easier to let the customers pull value from you as they need it.
  • Perfection – Work towards perfection through endless steps. Perfection of what, you might ask? Perfection in what you do to create value for the customer at each stage of the buying cycle.

Six Sigma: fact-based management

Once you have made your Sales and Marketing process Lean by creating a series of value-creating steps that flow, then you can focus on improving the quality of the value you create. Here is how Mike Webb describes the core principles of Six Sigma for Sales and Marketing.

  1. Create Value for Customers: A company exists to create and sell something of value to customers; that’s the North Star that must guide all our activities.
  2. Manage Data and Facts: We need measurements, data, and facts on what we’re doing and the results we’re getting before we make decisions; otherwise, we’re operating from opinion and politics.
  3. Analyze Cause-and-Effect: A problem occurs for a reason; if we find the cause of a problem and eliminate it, then we’ve solved the problem.
  4. Minimize Waste, Errors, and Defects: Like a watch or a car, a business process should have all the parts it requires, and do everything it’s supposed to do and nothing else; if we rid the process of useless activities and eliminate or at least minimize mistakes, the process will run correctly and produce the intended results.
  5. Create Collaboration: All process improvement methods recognize that business activities and functions are interconnected and that they all have to work together for any of them to succeed.

Regardless of your size, your industry, or your customer, the principles of Lean and Six Sigma enable companies to improve the speed with which buyers move through the pipeline and the quality of buyers that become customers.

Challenges in B2B Marketing and Sales

The problems in Marketing and Sales are familiar:

  • How do we attract new customers?
  • Why don’t our customers buy? Or, why DO they buy?
  • How much should we invest in Sales and Marketing? Where should we invest it? How do we know if we are getting a good return?
  • Which Marketing and Sales activities are producing results? What should we measure?

Facing a challenge

These challenges are compounded by the fact that power has shifted to the customer. In most of the world, customers have lots of choices and supply exceeds demand. The internet makes more information available to buyers. Information that sellers used to control is now widely available.

And the business buying process is more complex. More people are involved, products are more technical, buyers face integration issues, budgets are difficult to get approved.

Consequently, buyers face a lengthy journey in order to solve complex problems at their organization. At each stage of this journey they must answer certain questions and solve specific problems before they can continue to the next stage.

The Buyer's Journey

The Buyer's Journey

Organizations that want to help their buyers solve a problem know what to do. At each stage they help buyers answer their questions, solve their problems, and motivate them to continue to the next stage.

This, then, is the response to the challenge. The primary function of Marketing and Sales is to create value that motivates buyers to move from stage to stage in their journey.

Need an alternative to the elevator pitch?

Come hither hand gesture, inviting but ambiguous

Come hither hand gesture, inviting but ambiguous

You meet someone new. It’s someone who is a potential client or customer and they ask “What do you do?” You’ve probably read in business networking articles how to respond. Qualify them right away. See if they are a potential client. Find out which of your products or services might interest them.

How’s that working for you? Do you find it a natural way to initiate a relationship and build rapport? Does it feel forced?

Me too. I always found it awkward. I felt I was putting the other person in a difficult position.

Stephanie Palmer in her book Good in a Room recommends another approach. She suggests using teasers.

What’s a teaser? You can see an example just by turning on the television. Teasers are used by your local television news show every night: “Is your medicine cabinet a death trap? Find out more at 11!”

Teasers in a conversation arouse the other person’s curiosity but allow them to remain in control of the conversation. If the other person is curious and asks for more, you can respond. If the potential buyer doesn’t respond and moves the subject in another direction, so be it. You’ll still be developing rapport with the other person in a natural way.

It’s important for the other person to be in control at this stage because your goal is to learn about them. The way to learn is to allow them to open up and speak about the subjects that interest them.

Teasers according to Palmer should always be S.M.A.R.T.:

  • S: short
  • M: memorable – it should stand out or have some drama
  • A: accurate – correctly represent who you are and what you do
  • R: repeatable – sounds good when spoken
  • T: tonally appropriate – fits with the nature and style of your project or company

She describes three forms of teasers: startling statistics, purposely nonspecific phrases, and long term benefits. Here’s how a software project manager might use these three forms.

Startling statistics
Find some accurate statistics about your industry that reveal a surprising fact. They upset the worldview of your listener and the other person will often want to know more. You can knit their worldview back together and resolve the conflicting ideas.

“You’ve probably heard that 70% of all software projects fail. I make sure that my clients are in that other 30%.”

Purposely nonspecific phrases
When you are meeting someone who is unlikely to be knowledgeable about your field, a nonspecific phrase can be effective at arousing curiosity. If they ask what you mean, you can continue. If they don’t, you can let it go and leave the other person in control of the direction of the conversation.

“I’m a coach for software projects.”

Long term benefit
Long term benefits are attractive because they indicate that you develop long term relationships and that people trust you.

“I help software teams build a long history of successful projects.”

Developing teasers is not easy. It takes some work and some experimentation. But every experiment is valuable. You’ll learn what works and what doesn’t. You’ll figure out which teasers work in different types of situations and with different types of people.

And even when a teaser doesn’t seem to work, the interactions are still successful because you are allowing the other person to remain in control and to leave the interaction with a positive feeling. You both leave the interaction with increased rapport.